From Erdoğan–Erbakan to İmamoğlu–Kılıçdaroğlu: Is Turkey Facing Another Political Realignment?

In the late 1990s, Turkey’s political map was redrawn by a deep fracture within the Islamist movement. A young and ambitious Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, along with other reformists, broke ranks with Necmettin Erbakan and the rigid doctrines of Milli Görüş (National Vision). Their new party—the Justice and Development Party (AKP- (AKP- Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi)—embraced a more flexible, pro-European, and…

Decentralization Without Division: A Syrian Model Inspired by Turkey’s Law 6360

After years of political fragmentation, civil war, displacement, and military stalemate, the question of Syria’s future governance is no longer abstract — it is urgent. In a landmark moment this April, a coalition of Syrian Kurdish political forces issued a joint declaration calling for a “democratic and decentralized Syria.” The document proposes a new constitutional order that upholds the territorial…

Erdoğan’s Advisory Councils: Nothing but a Political Stage Prop

New revelations from İlnur Çevik, a former senior advisor to President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, have exposed the hollow nature of Turkey’s presidential advisory system — revealing it to be little more than a political stage prop, designed to project an image of consultation while Erdoğan centralized all decision-making power in his own hands. İlnur Çevik, a veteran journalist and political…

Editor's Pick

UK Says Eurofighter Jet Sale to Turkey Has Backing of All Consortium Members

Turkey’s long-sought purchase of Eurofighter Typhoon jets has taken a significant step…

Turkey Signs MoUs to Link Seven African Nations to Global Trade Corridors

Turkey has signed memoranda of understanding (MoUs) with seven African countries to…

PKK to Lay Down Arms in Sulaimaniyah Ceremony as Part of New Peace Push

Militants from the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) are expected to formally…

Turkish Court Postpones High-Stakes CHP Trial to September Amid Allegations of Political Interference

A politically charged trial that could reshape the leadership of Turkey’s main…

Libyan Parliament Reportedly Moves Toward Ratification of 2019 Maritime Deal with Turkey

Libya’s House of Representatives (HoR) is reportedly moving toward a ratification of…

Turkey–U.S. Set to Resolve S-400 Dispute by Year’s End, Says U.S. Ambassador

The long-standing standoff between Turkey and the United States over Ankara’s purchase…

Belgian Authorities Seize Cocaine Shipment from Turkish-Operated Tanker, Detain 13 Suspects

Belgian customs authorities have seized a substantial quantity of cocaine from the…

267 People Detained This Week in Turkey’s Ongoing Operations Against Gülen Movement

Turkish authorities have detained 267 people since Tuesday, including 14 police officers…

“I Lost My Wife, My Daughter — Now My Son Is in Prison”: A Father’s Grief After Turkey’s Purge

A former Turkish civil servant whose life was upended by the government’s…

13 Arrested in Turkey as Crackdown on Gülen Movement-Linked Businesses Intensifies

A Turkish court on Friday ordered the formal arrest of 13 individuals…

Turkish Police Raid Dessert Chain Over Alleged Gülen Movement Ties

Turkish police detained 33 individuals on Monday in coordinated dawn raids targeting…

Turkey’s Endless Purge: Military Officers Arrested in Latest Crackdown on Alleged Gülenists

Istanbul – May 23, 2025 — The Istanbul Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office…

Mass Detentions in Turkey: 77 Jailed Over Routine Activities Tied to Gülen Movement

Gaziantep, Turkey — Turkish authorities have jailed at least 77 individuals, many…

Turkey Detains 320, Mostly Students, in Widening Crackdown on Alleged Gülen Affiliates

The number of people detained this week in a nationwide crackdown on…

Turkey Detains 23 in Ongoing Crackdown on Gülen-Linked Döner Chain

Turkish police detained 23 individuals on Friday in a renewed wave of…

Turkey Detains 208 in Nationwide Crackdown on Gülen Movement

Turkish authorities detained 208 individuals across 47 provinces on Tuesday for alleged…

Kyrgyz Teacher Disappears After Reported Detention at Istanbul Airport

A Kyrgyz mathematics teacher has reportedly gone missing after being detained by…

Purged Teacher Barred from School Bus Job in Turkey, Prompting Outcry

A former teacher who was dismissed under a government decree following the…

ECtHR Rules Turkey Violated Human Rights by Arresting 51 Judges and Prosecutors After 2016 Coup

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has ruled that Turkey violated…

Dutch Government Report Highlights Continued Crackdown on Alleged Gülenists in Turkey

A newly released report by the Dutch Ministry of Justice and Security…

Turkey Detains 353 Over Alleged Ties to Gülen Movement in Nationwide Crackdown

Turkish authorities have detained 353 individuals over alleged ties to the faith-based…

Turkish Authorities Detain 17 Doctors Over Alleged Gülen Movement Ties in Nationwide Raids

Turkish authorities have detained 17 medical professionals in a series of coordinated…

From Erdoğan–Erbakan to İmamoğlu–Kılıçdaroğlu: Is Turkey Facing Another Political Realignment?

In the late 1990s, Turkey’s political map was redrawn by a deep fracture within the Islamist movement. A young and ambitious Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, along with other reformists, broke ranks with Necmettin Erbakan and the rigid doctrines of Milli Görüş (National Vision). Their new party—the Justice and Development Party (AKP- (AKP- Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi)—embraced a more flexible, pro-European, and market-friendly vision. It attracted conservatives disillusioned with old-school Islamism and centrists yearning for change. This pivot wasn’t just cosmetic—it fueled a political upheaval. The AKP's sweeping win in the 2002 elections didn’t just launch Erdoğan’s rise; it effectively buried Turkey’s fractured center-right and birthed a new political era. Fast forward to today, and a different but equally consequential split is brewing—this time inside the main opposition party, the CHP: A court case threatens to annul the 2023 convention results that installed Özgür Özel as party leader—potentially reinstating ex-leader Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu. After this congress, the party achieved historic success in the 2024 municipal elections—its first nationwide plurality since 1977.  With a court decision expected on June 30, the 2023 congress may be annulled due to alleged procedural irregularities and vote-buying allegations. Kılıçdaroğlu has signalled his intention to reclaim the party leadership through judicial channels—arguing that refusing to comply with a court ruling could lead to the appointment of a state trustee. From prison, Ekrem İmamoğlu has accused Kılıçdaroğlu of betrayal, warning that this power play threatens not just party unity but the broader hope for democratic renewal. “He wants to bury me in concrete,” İmamoğlu reportedly told allies, expressing deep emotional pain at being politically sidelined. His frustration echoes the reformist anguish of Erdoğan in the 1990s, when the old guard refused to yield despite a clear mandate for change. Erdoğan and İmamoğlu: Striking Parallels There are several political, social, and cultural similarities between Erdoğan and İmamoğlu. The parallels become even more striking when considering their shared beginnings as mayors of Istanbul, Turkey’s most influential and symbolically powerful city. Erdoğan held the position from 1994 to 1998, earning national recognition for his pragmatic and effective municipal governance. Two decades later, İmamoğlu followed a similar trajectory, serving from 2019 until his suspension in 2025. For both leaders, the Istanbul mayoralty served as a critical launching pad—providing executive experience and national visibility grounded in tangible service delivery rather than partisan ideology. Erdoğan’s early political success was built on visible urban reforms—cleaning up the Golden Horn, lowering public transit fares, and running social aid campaigns for the needy. İmamoğlu adopted a similar playbook during his tenure as mayor of Istanbul, focusing on inclusive policies that aimed to empower youth and women while addressing the city’s long-standing urban inequalities. One of his signature initiatives was the introduction of affordable municipal dining halls (Kent Lokantaları), which offered low-cost meals to students and low-income residents throughout the city. Like Erdoğan before him, İmamoğlu emphasized practical, people-focused governance—an approach that allowed him to cultivate broad-based grassroots support and build public trust beyond partisan lines. However, when comparing their respective legacies, Erdoğan proved to be a more transformative and politically effective mayor. His tenure not only improved municipal services but also laid the groundwork for his rapid ascent to national leadership—a momentum İmamoğlu has yet to fully replicate. Both Erdoğan and İmamoğlu share cultural and social traits that amplify their populist appeal. Hailing from the Black Sea region—Erdoğan from Rize and İmamoğlu from Trabzon—and with backgrounds as passionate amateur footballers, they have each crafted a relatable, everyman image that resonates with broad segments of the electorate. Beyond cultural familiarity, both have also strategically used religion to bolster their public personas. While Erdoğan integrates religious symbolism into his political identity, İmamoğlu employs a more subtle but deliberate engagement with faith-based communities, positioning himself as respectful of religious values without alienating secular voters. This calibrated use of religion, alongside their shared regional roots and approachable charisma, has helped both men build emotional connections with the public that transcend partisan lines. A striking parallel lies in how legal persecution acted as a political accelerant. Erdoğan’s 1999 imprisonment for publicly reciting a poem turned him into a political martyr, catalyzing his rise to national power. İmamoğlu’s imprisonment and suspension from office in 2025, widely seen as politically motivated, triggered nationwide protests and significantly boosted his national profile. Prior to that, he was sentenced for allegedly insulting members of the election board, a charge that resulted in a political ban—now under appeal. In a further blow, his university diploma was annulled, casting uncertainty over his eligibility for public office. In addition to these developments, İmamoğlu is facing several other criminal investigations, many of which also carry the risk of political bans, reinforcing widespread concerns that legal tools are being weaponized to eliminate him from the political arena.. Yet, the context today differs: whereas Erdoğan rose at a time of growing democratic optimism shaped by European Union (EU) accession talks, press pluralism, and economic expansion, İmamoğlu faces an authoritarian political landscape with a cowed media, co-opted judiciary, and fractured opposition.. The conditions that helped Erdoğan ride a wave to power are far less favorable now. Erdoğan Built the AKP—Could İmamoğlu Build Something New? Necmettin Erbakan, the founder of the Milli Görüş movement, remained committed to a rigid, ideologically driven agenda rooted in political Islam. His refusal to adapt doomed his movement to irrelevance. He alienated Turkey’s reform-minded conservatives with outdated rhetoric and confrontational anti-Westernism. His confrontational approach—especially his attempts to challenge Turkey’s secular order—alarmed the entrenched Kemalist establishment, particularly the military, judiciary, and high bureaucracy. In response, the so-called "postmodern coup" of 1997 forced Erbakan from office, and shortly thereafter, his Welfare Party (Refah Partisi) was banned by the Constitutional Court. This judicial offensive was followed by the banning of its successor, the Virtue Party (Fazilet Partisi), in 2001. These moves were not just about outlawing parties—they aimed to fragment and ultimately dissolve the rising political influence of religious conservatives. Ironically, this strategy backfired. The sustained legal and institutional pressure catalyzed a reformist break from Erbakan’s…

Recent Turkish Infiltration Raises Security Concerns at Syrian Camp

WASHINGTON - A recent Turkish intelligence operation inside a camp holding thousands of displaced people, including families of Islamic State fighters, exposes serious security vulnerabilities that could harm U.S.-backed Syrian…

EP Turkey rapporteur says ‘geopolitics not an excuse for deficit of democracy’

The process for Turkey’s accession to the European Union cannot simply be overridden by geopolitics, European Parliament Standing Rapporteur for Turkey Nacho Sánchez Amor said in a statement issued following his recent…