Dynasty in the Making: ‘Gaza Solidarity’ Rallies and the Succession of Bilal Erdoğan

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has built his political career on a blend of Islamic 'solidarity', populist rhetoric, and shrewd political choreography. Now, as Turkey’s long-serving president enters his third decade in power, the stage is being set for a new chapter — one in which his son, Bilal Erdoğan, increasingly occupies the political spotlight. The August 9 “Be a Light of…

Democratic Confederalism: End of the Nation-State or Turkish-Led Integration under Confederation?

A new and important chapter in Kurdish politics has begun with the PKK's official disbandment after Abdullah Öcalan called for peace and a democratic society. This change isn't only about stopping the fighting; it's also about changing what power, identity, and statehood mean in the 21st century. The idea of "positive integration" and the use of Öcalan's model of democratic…

The Mind Games of Turkey’s Spy Chief and His Quiet Coup: From Gülenist Circles to Kurdish Talks

In the final phase of Erdoğan’s two-decade rule, a quieter, more calculating force has begun defining the regime’s future: İbrahim Kalın, Turkey’s intelligence chief, presidential confidant, and now de facto architect of what comes after Erdoğan. Though he rarely occupies headlines, Kalın is shaping the post-Erdoğan state through two powerful—but distinct—operations: the divide-and-co-opt campaign targeting the Gülen movement, and the…

Editor's Pick

Dynasty in the Making: ‘Gaza Solidarity’ Rallies and the Succession of Bilal Erdoğan

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has built his political career on a blend of…

From PhD to BA: Our Early Exposé on Fidan’s Degrees Was Only the Tip of the Iceberg

On June 3, 2023, when President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan appointed Hakan Fidan…

From Nine Lights to Nine Regions: MHP’s Message Stirs Federalism Debate

A new public campaign launched by Turkey’s Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) has…

Majority of Turks Back General Amnesty Amid Kurdish Peace Push and Prison Crisis

A majority of Turkish citizens support the idea of a general amnesty,…

Forgery Scandal Exposes Systemic Decay

A sprawling digital forgery scandal has sent shockwaves across Turkey, exposing deep…

Turkey Jails First Conscientious Objector in a Decade

A court in Sivas has sentenced conscientious objector Çınar Koçgiri Doğan to…

Turkey Equates Gülenists with MEK in Bid to Brand Them Global ‘Terrorists’

A newly released report from Turkey’s National Intelligence Academy, a body affiliated…

The Mind Games of Turkey’s Spy Chief and His Quiet Coup: From Gülenist Circles to Kurdish Talks

In the final phase of Erdoğan’s two-decade rule, a quieter, more calculating…

Erdoğan’s Divide-and-Coopt Strategy: A New Phase in the War on Gülenists

Turkey’s long-running campaign against the Gülen movement has entered a new and…

Turkey’s Unfinished Purge: 77 More Detained in Crackdown on Gülen Movement

Turkey has detained 77 individuals in a new wave of operations targeting…

Post-Coup Purge Left 95% of Turkey’s Staff Officers Dismissed, Defense Official Confirms

A senior official from Turkey’s Ministry of National Defense has revealed that…

267 People Detained This Week in Turkey’s Ongoing Operations Against Gülen Movement

Turkish authorities have detained 267 people since Tuesday, including 14 police officers…

“I Lost My Wife, My Daughter — Now My Son Is in Prison”: A Father’s Grief After Turkey’s Purge

A former Turkish civil servant whose life was upended by the government’s…

13 Arrested in Turkey as Crackdown on Gülen Movement-Linked Businesses Intensifies

A Turkish court on Friday ordered the formal arrest of 13 individuals…

Turkish Police Raid Dessert Chain Over Alleged Gülen Movement Ties

Turkish police detained 33 individuals on Monday in coordinated dawn raids targeting…

Turkey’s Endless Purge: Military Officers Arrested in Latest Crackdown on Alleged Gülenists

Istanbul – May 23, 2025 — The Istanbul Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office…

Mass Detentions in Turkey: 77 Jailed Over Routine Activities Tied to Gülen Movement

Gaziantep, Turkey — Turkish authorities have jailed at least 77 individuals, many…

Turkey Detains 320, Mostly Students, in Widening Crackdown on Alleged Gülen Affiliates

The number of people detained this week in a nationwide crackdown on…

Turkey Detains 23 in Ongoing Crackdown on Gülen-Linked Döner Chain

Turkish police detained 23 individuals on Friday in a renewed wave of…

Turkey Detains 208 in Nationwide Crackdown on Gülen Movement

Turkish authorities detained 208 individuals across 47 provinces on Tuesday for alleged…

Dynasty in the Making: ‘Gaza Solidarity’ Rallies and the Succession of Bilal Erdoğan

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has built his political career on a blend of Islamic 'solidarity', populist rhetoric, and shrewd political choreography. Now, as Turkey’s long-serving president enters his third decade in power, the stage is being set for a new chapter — one in which his son, Bilal Erdoğan, increasingly occupies the political spotlight. The August 9 “Be a Light of Hope for Gaza” march in Istanbul offered more than just a display of 'solidarity' with Palestinians. It was, in many ways, a carefully crafted showcase for Bilal’s growing public profile. The march, organized by the Support for Palestine Platform, drew thousands from Beyazıt Square to Hagia Sophia — a route steeped in meaning for Turkey’s religious and nationalist base. Bilal Erdoğan, serving as chairman of the İlim Yayma Vakfı board of trustees, was among those calling for the rally, standing shoulder to shoulder with other prominent figures, including his brother-in-law, Baykar defense executive Selçuk Bayraktar. It was a scene heavy with symbolism: the president’s son and son-in-law leading a cause rooted in Islamic heritage, Ottoman nostalgia, and the Palestinian struggle — all core themes of Erdoğan’s political identity. It was not Bilal’s first time in such a role. Back in January, he had helped spearhead a similar Gaza solidarity march on Istanbul’s Galata Bridge, again placing himself at the forefront of a movement that blends religious sentiment with political messaging. The August rally, like the one in January, underscored his growing role as a public face for causes that resonate deeply with the AKP’s conservative base. Just hours before the march, he sat for a lengthy interview on Habertürk TV. The visual and auditory echoes of his father were striking: the same deliberate cadence, the same moral-political framing, the same ease in pivoting from local symbolism to global critique. “We thought holding the march in the evening would both increase participation and create beautiful visuals,” he explained, openly acknowledging the event’s media-conscious design. “The Palestinian issue is truly a matter of human conscience… We’ve reached a point where we must ask: is humanity’s conscience dying?” Bilal’s commentary was not limited to poetic lamentation. He directly accused the West of moral failure, noting that “those who speak most about democracy” have the power to stop Israel’s actions but choose not to. He pointed to the entrenched influence of the pro-Israel lobby in the United States, the weight of Holocaust guilt in Germany’s foreign policy, and recent cracks in this consensus, such as Berlin’s decision to suspend certain arms sales to Israel. This is vintage Erdoğanism — the fusion of moral outrage, geopolitical critique, and civilizational framing — but now articulated by the president’s son. In a telling moment, Bilal shared a story his father once told him: During the U.S. war in Vietnam, an old man stood outside the White House every day, lighting a candle. A journalist asked why he did it, knowing it wouldn’t change anything. The old man replied, ‘I know I can’t change them—but I don’t want them to change me.’ That, Bilal said, is the essence: to stand firm, to be part of the story, to keep the memory alive, and to pass it on to our children." The effect of this performance was twofold: it reinforced the AKP’s positioning as the moral vanguard of the Muslim world, and it tested Bilal’s ability to inhabit a role that combines humanitarian rhetoric with political mobilization. His discourse ranged from calls for greater media production on Palestine — “Why can’t we make a powerful film about a Palestinian child’s story?” — to critiques of Israel’s decades-long regional strategy of weakening neighboring states. He invoked the late Islamist leader Necmettin Erbakan’s warnings about Israeli ambitions, explicitly situating himself in the ideological lineage that shaped his father’s early political career. He also claimed that Israel has spent decades undermining countries across the region — from Iraq to Syria to Libya — to secure its own freedom of action. He noted that Erbakan Hodja had warned about this 40 years ago, yet despite witnessing it unfold, the region still cannot act decisively. What he failed to acknowledge, however, is that every one of these events took place during his father’s tenure — and in each case, his father was not merely a bystander, but a key actor. The infrastructure supporting this positioning is extensive. Bilal’s leadership of TÜGVA and the İlim Yayma Vakfı places him at the center of networks that cultivate conservative youth, religious educators, and community organizers. These institutions function like political greenhouses, nurturing loyal cadres who can later assume roles across public institutions and civil society. Within this framework, Bilal has come to be seen by many as an “undeclared crown prince,” exercising considerable influence without holding elected office. The broader system — built on the centralization of power, the capture of institutions, and the tight integration of civil society into the ruling network — is well suited to facilitating such a succession from within. Critics, however, see danger in this trajectory. Gaza’s tragedy, they argue, is being instrumentalized for domestic political purposes. The government’s selective tolerance of protests supports this view: the August 9 Istanbul march, attended by AKP figures and aligned with official messaging, was celebrated. Yet in Ankara, just hours earlier, police detained five activists attempting to deliver a letter to President Erdoğan demanding a full break in trade with Israel. These activists were released without charge, but the message was clear — public dissent is welcome when choreographed under the auspices of the Turkish government; disruptive or independent mobilization is to be contained. On paper, Ankara declared a sweeping embargo on Israel in May 2024. In practice, Israeli import data tells a different story: nearly $400 million in Turkish goods flowed into Israel between January and May 2025. For critics, the numbers speak louder than the speeches. They point to indirect trade routes quietly keeping business ties alive, even as the government wraps itself in the moral banner of Gaza. To them, this…